International Football

World Cup 2014: No Neymar, no chance? – Brazil v Germany

Belo HorizoneteThe various permutations for the World Cup final make for intriguing discussions – in an ideal FIFA world, they’re probably hoping for a clash of the South American titans, Brazil v Argentina. If the diplomats have their way, it will be Brazil v Netherlands or Germany v Argentina (please, no). But given the law of coincidence often delivers the unlikely in football, Germany v Netherlands – exactly 40 years after the two nations met in Munich, will be a classic. I am sure that this has not been lost on the Dutch, who have been waiting four decades to get their revenge on the Germans.

However, Germany have to beat the host nation to make this a reality, and emotions will be running high on Tuesday night in Belo Horizonte. With Neymar sidelined and Thiago Silva injured, the Brazilians have been shorn of their two best players. They have been very much a one-man show and without the talismanic Barcelona player, Brazil will look very workmanlike.

Brazil’s approach to this competition has confirmed once and for all that “jogo bonito” died in Italy in 1982. You can thank Paulo Rossi for that. It’s more Dunga than Didi.

Brazil have not convinced anyone in their five games so far. Only against Cameroon have they demonstrated their heritage, and let’s face it, that is not much to boast about. Against Croatia, they were scruffy, but had to thank Neymar; against Mexico they were a blunt instrument; they were downright lucky against Chile; and Colombia were only marginally beaten. They have complained about the treatment of Neymar, yet their own handling of James Rodriguez was, at times, brutal. And Fernandinho was lucky to stay on the pitch.

1970 legend Tostao has said in public that Brazil have two tactics: 1 – give it to Neymar; 2- give it to Neymar. It doesn’t bode well..

Brazil’s road to Belo Horizonte
Croatia W 3-1 (Neymar 2, Oscar)
Mexico D 0-0
Cameroon W 4-1 (Neymar 2, Fred, Fernandinho)
R/16 – Chile D 1-1 (Luiz) won on pens
QF – Colombia W 2-1 (Thiago Silva, Luiz)

Appearances (including sub apps.)
5- Julio Cesar, Thiago Silva, Marcelo, Oscar, Neymar, Fred, Ramires ; 4- Alves, Paulinho, Gustavo, Hulk, Luiz; 3- Willian, Fernandinho; 2- Hernanes, Bernard, Jo; 1- Henrique, Maicon

Germany, with the exception of the opening game against Portugal, have been underwhelming at times. But as always, they are professional in the extreme, efficient and economical with their mistakes. They have a lack of firepower – a country of their standing should not be relying on a veteran like Klose for goals (although he has done it again!). But they have players that can run at, and get behind a defence, like Ozil, Mueller and Schurrle, who has looked good in his appearances as substitute.

Given that Brazil’s defence is lacking the excellent Silva, Ozil and Mueller could prove to be the hosts’ undoing.

Germany’s road to Belo Horizonte
Portugal W 4-0 (Mueller 3, Hummels)
Ghana D 2-2 (Goetze, Klose)
USA W 1-0 (Mueller)
R/16 – Algeria W 2-1 (Schurrrle, Ozil)
QF – France W 1-0 (Hummels)

Appearances (including sub apps)
5- Neuer, Boateng, Howedes, Lahm, Ozil, Goetze, Kroos, Mueller; 4- Khedira, Hummels, Schurrle, Mertesacker, Schweinsteiger; 3- Mustafi, Klose; 2- Kramer, Podolski

Surprisingly, Brazil and Germany have met just once before in World Cup action, and that was the 2002 final in Japan.

Brazil have been on this “date of destiny” trip since the competition started and there’s something a little presumptious about it all. They used to be everyone’s second favourite team, but this attitude of “we are on a journey to win the World Cup” is starting to grate. That said, their route to the final is all become a little inevitable, and having disposed of Chile and Colombia, both teams that are arguably better than Scolari’s selection, the tidal wave of emotion will be expected to take them over the penultimate hurdle. But never, never write-off Germany. It will be a tense night and all we can ask for is an exciting semi-final to compensate for a lousy batch of quarter-final ties.

1 reply »

  1. Save for the very first game (which was won 4:0, with two goals in the lead even before the red card), Germany had to break though teams with very tight defences. Don’t underestimate their fire-power: All players in the offensive midfield are able to score, which is the reason why Klose is the only pure striker in the squad.

    I would have bet on Germany from the get go, for the simple reason that they are very organized, and won’t allow Brazil to force them to play the rough game. Now that the German defence stands tight and all players are at least healthy again (that’s another thing Germany had to struggle with), the only thing which might make the next game difficult is not knowing how the Brazil Coach will react to the loss of two players. That makes it kind of difficult to find the right strategy.

    I guess Brazil can only win in this encounter…if they win, it will be celebrated as overcoming dire circumstances. But if they loose, there will the nice little fairy tale about the World Cup which was taken from them because of an unfair foul.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s