Every day, the folly of Qatar 2022 is exposed

THE WORLD Cup is underway and Ecuador have inflicted the first defeat on the hosts, the only home nation to be beaten in their opening game in the competition’s history. If the sceptics want some consolation about Qatar’s tarnished World Cup, it will surely be an early exit and no more than three games. The Asian champions, overawed and unable to rise to the occasion, were that ineffective.

Gianni Infantino has been digging himself into a hole for weeks and on the eve of the first game, made an eccentric, outrageous and desperate justification speech. Who the hell wrote this for him? He was at it again when he grabbed a microphone, Karaoke style and insisted: “Football unites the world and now let’s welcome the teams and let the show begin. All the best to everyone.”

Meanwhile, Qatar has prevented fans from enjoying a drink unless they are kettled into the FIFA fan parks, paying extortionate prices in an easily-managed camp. The accommodation, almost mirroring migrant workers’ centres, are ludicrously spartan, expensive and primitive. Qatar may consider they are welcoming the world but there are simply treating it with contempt. And still they claim inclusiveness is their aim – does anybody really believe any of this nonsense?

World Cups used to be about carnival, about different nationalities mixing with each other, raising a glass and sharing experiences. Yes, there were also those that treated the football jamboree as an opportunity to behave like Neanderthals, but the normal, rational fan enjoyed the pot-pourri of different cultures present in the name of football. Qatar, which is scarcely a destination of choice for most folk, doesn’t really know what it is hosting – you can buy shameful celebrity endorsement, as we have seen, but does Qatar really understand the cultural and social significance?

It is early days, but it is feasible Qatar will be tested by the irrational emotions and passions of the game. Imagine if England struggle in their group games and the fans are disappointed. Supporters that have experienced the limitations. Will we see a reaction that forces the local security services to act? With so many people in a relatively confined space, how will Qatar react to crowd violence?

The World Cup will be a success, because we will be told that it was a success. FIFA will tell us, Qatar will tell us and enough celebrity puppets will come to the fore to say they had a “wonderful time”. But the truth is, FIFA have facilitated sportswashing and as the sport’s governing body, this act of folly is irresponsible and not in the best interests of the sport. Admittedly, some clubs are also guilty of this, but the difference is FIFA should be acting as guardians and gatekeepers.

Qatar has to realise scores of people will be digging for dirt and bad news will filter from the middle east every day of the World Cup. Why? Because that’s their job and it also helps justify them being there. Many journalists are uncomfortable about going to Qatar, and rightly so. Whether it all passes without a hitch or not, Qatar 2022 is simply wrong.

Copa Libertadores: Another all-Brazilian affair

FOR THE third successive season, two teams from Brazil will contest the Copa Libertadores final. This time, it is Flamengo against surprise package Athletico Paranaense, who happen to be managed by Luiz Felipe Scolari, a man who knows how to win the competition.

Scolari won in 1995 and 1999 with Grêmio and Palmeiras respectively, and of course, he also won the World Cup with Brazil in 2002. At 73, he’s approaching the end of his marvellous career – he has hinted this may be his last year – and his side go into the final in Ecuador as underdogs although nobody is writing them off.

As ever, the Copa Libertadores provides a very vivid shop window for players looking for that lucrative and career-defining move to Europe. This year, clubs from the top leagues will be watching AP’s 17 year-old Vitor Roque, who has sparkled in the competition, as well as Flamengo’s João Gomes, who has been catching the eye of none other than Liverpool, Real Madrid and Barcelona. In addition to young talent like Roque, AP have been boosted this year by 37 year-old Fernandinho, who joined the club after leaving Manchester City. Flamengo, meanwhile, have a trio of well-known veterans in their squad in David Luiz, Felipe Luis and Arturo Vidal. While some see this exodus of players from Europe as a positive, it has to be remembered they are in the autumn of their careers.

Although AP are not part of the G-12 clubs that heavily influence Brazilian football, they are seen as the strongest from outside that group and they have the largest number of fans in their home city of Curitiba. They won the Copa Sudamericana last year, beating another Brazilian side, Red Bull Bragantino, in the final in Montevideo.  

But AP, from a financial perspective, are a mid-table club in Brazil. In 2021, their total revenues were US$ 50 million, more than 20% lower than in 2020. The club has debts of around US$ 35 million. Flamengo are a considerably bigger club and can draw crowds of 50,000. Their total income was close to US$ 200 million in 2021, but their debts are over US$ 75 million.

AP finished second in their Libertadores group, behind Paraguay’s Libertad, whom they met in the round of 16 and beat. They then overcame Estudiantes (Argentina) and Palmeiras, the champions-elect in Brazil. Most experts expected a repeat of 2021’s final, Flamengo versus Palmeiras, but AP upset the form book.

Flamengo and Palmeiras are increasingly being referred to as the Real Madrid and Barcelona of Brazil and are part of what people are calling “the LaLigaisation of Brazilian football”. They are certainly at the forefront of the nation’s bid to make their domestic game more accessible around the world. From CONMEBOL’s perspective, if they want the Copa Libertadores to become a more global event, these two clubs have a growing profile in other continents. Flamengo have won the Brazilian title twice and finished runners-up twice in the last four years. They are likely to finish third this year after a poor start to the campaign, which effectively cost coach Paulo Sousa his job earlier this year.

But this could turn out to be a memorable season for the Rio de Janeiro-based club; they have already finished runners-up in their state championship, they are in the Copa do Brasil final, the Libertadores final and they are in the top three of the league. They face Corinthians in the second leg of the final on October 19 in the Maracana stadium after drawing 0-0 in the first leg in Säo Paulo. Flamengo will be without Gomes, who is suspended. There is every chance that Flamengo could end 2022 with nothing to show for their considerable efforts.

Flamengo’s Copa Libertadores displays have been impressive and they have won 10 of their 11 ties and drawn once. Moreover, they have scored 32 goals. They beat Velez Sarsfield of Argentina in the semi-finals 6-1 on aggregate and also disposed of Corinthians on the way to the final. Their group was relatively unchallenging and included Sporting Cristal of Peru and another Argentinian side, Talleres.

It would not be the Copa Libertadores without some sort of controversy and this year, the choice of Guayaquil has been questioned. Guayaquil has become a very violent place as gang violence and drug wars have created a relatively unsafe city. The Brazilian news site Globo Esporte suggested that Guayaquil did not have the necessary infrastructure to stage the final, while others have called for CONMEBOL to select an alternative venue. According to the Guardian, Guayaquil is one of the 50 most violent cities in the world based on research by InSight Crime. Against this backdrop, the Estadio Monumental is sure to crackle with tension on October 29.