Books & Media

Football Media Watch: Sold a dream, given a nightmare on Green Street

West Ham United v Burnley - Premier League - London Stadium
Photo: PA

THE disconnect between West Ham United’s board and the club’s fans boiled over at the weekend, with protests, violence and symbolic gestures that made it crystal clear – the Hammers’ supporters are very unhappy.

The nature of the protest will bring West Ham trouble, but the fact there is an air of delusion about the club means that is will probably happen again.

A few days earlier, West Ham reported a profit of £48.5m for the year and vice-chairman Karren Brady said that the healthy profitability would still have been generated if the club had remained at Upton Park.

The Newham Recorder, who actually refer to the club as West Ham FC (surely, the fans cannot be happy with that?), said Brady attributed the financial results to the broadcasting deal and player sales.

Brady has described the controversial new ground as “one of the great arenas of world football”. Very few would agree with that description of a stadium that has been at the root cause of the angst among the club’s followers.

It’s a stadium that has a toxic atmosphere, so much so Hammers legend, Trevor Brooking, said in The Times that unhappy fans should stay away as their mood could end with West Ham being relegated.

Were West Ham fans ever going to be happy leaving their homely, but limited, home at the Boleyn? The Football Writers’ Podcast this week commented that the stadium experience is not particularly pleasant, from the walk to the ground from the railway station to the adjoining shopping centre.

The Evening Standard’s John Dillon said many people believe the old club has gone and cannot be replaced. He has a point, but West Ham are not going to be going anywhere fast, even though the relocation has, so far, been a disaster. The truth is, West Ham fans loved Upton Park, its atmosphere and the fact it was intimidating for opponents. Today, they have a huge, lifeless bowl where the action seems miles away. It was good for the Olympics six years ago, but not for football.

Dillon distances the trouble at the stadium from old-style hooliganism from the past. “Such scenes capture how profound the whole rotten, toxic mess at West Ham is rooted in the bewilderment of the fans over the lost heritage and the empty soulnessness of what has replaced it.”

Still, Brady has described the move from Upton Park as one of the most successful stadium migrations. At the end of February, SKY Sports reported the club has committed to a study with a view to making changes at the London Stadium. Brady would be advised to “fast track” the programme in order to heal the gaping wounds in Stratford. No surprise that season ticket prices have been frozen for 2018-19!

2 comments

  1. Upton Park was more initimidating for the oppositions followers. than it ever was for the opposition players. Many players are quoted as saying how Upton Park “was intimidating” The facts do not bare this out. If West Hams league position in a home table is compared to their overall position since 1958-59, (58 Upton Park seasons) they have a net tabled difference of 17 places in favour of home advantage. Given that this was achieved in the first three seasons of that period, It is safe to conclude that there was no Upton Park “factor”. Added to that the ground was cramped by its environs in a place that few fans lived, with no parking facilities and poor transport options, it could not grow. Add 10000 to the capacity and it would not have been more attractive to sponsors, and the travel experience would not have improved.

    Upton Park has a nostalgic aura, but the facts bear no scrutiny.

  2. Personally, I always liked Upton Park, even when I visited as an opposition fan. 1977-78, West Ham v Chelsea, I was in the chicken run and Bill Garner, I think, gave Chelsea the lead. I dropped my guard and celebrated. I was intimidated. But I saw some good games there, not least the final game of 1976-77 when West Ham beat Man Utd 4-2 to stay up. Also, some of the ECWC games of 1975-76. My last visit was for the famous WBA Anelka salute. I was reminded that it was cramped, lacking potential for development etc. The club have to make the move work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.